Home › Guides › Proforma Invoice vs Commercial Invoice: When to Use Each
Proforma Invoice vs Commercial Invoice: When to Use Each
They look almost identical — same items, same totals — but a proforma invoice is a preliminary document that asks for no payment and books no sale, while a commercial invoice is the real one: it records the sale, supports customs clearance, and is what the buyer actually pays against.
What a proforma invoice is for
A proforma shows the buyer exactly what a final invoice would look like, before the sale is final. Buyers use it to arrange an advance payment, open a letter of credit, get import approval, or sign off the price internally. Because nothing has been sold yet, a proforma is not entered in your accounts as revenue, it is not a tax invoice, and the buyer cannot claim tax credit from it. It should be clearly marked "Proforma Invoice" and carry a validity period — prices and stock can change.
What a commercial invoice is for
A commercial invoice is issued when the sale actually happens. It is the document customs uses to value a shipment and assess duties, the document the buyer's accounts department pays against, and the document your own books record as the sale. For domestic sales the everyday invoice plays this role; for exports, the commercial invoice travels with the goods alongside the packing list.
Side by side
| Proforma invoice | Commercial invoice | |
|---|---|---|
| When | Before the sale — quote stage, advance payment | When the sale is made / goods ship |
| Payment | Not a demand for payment (may support an advance) | The document the buyer pays against |
| Accounting | Not recorded as a sale | Recorded as revenue / receivable |
| Tax | Not a tax invoice; no tax credit from it | Supports VAT / GST claims where applicable |
| Customs | Used for pre-approval and import licences | Used to clear the actual shipment and assess duty |
| Details | Marked "Proforma", with a validity date | Final quantities, weights, HS codes, country of origin |
The usual order of documents
- Quote / estimate — the price proposal the buyer approves (Quote / Estimate Generator).
- Proforma invoice — the approved deal in invoice form, used for the advance payment or import paperwork (Proforma Invoice Generator).
- Commercial invoice — issued at shipment or delivery; the advance is deducted and the balance billed (Customer Invoice Generator).
The rule of thumb: if the buyer needs the document to decide or prepare, send a proforma; if they need it to pay, clear or record the sale, send the commercial invoice. And never send both as if they were two charges — mark the proforma clearly, and reference it on the final invoice so the paper trail reads as one deal. New to invoicing altogether? Start with how to create an invoice.
Create a proforma invoice
Reference number, validity period, full buyer details and advance payment instructions — marked clearly as a proforma, not a tax invoice.
Open the Proforma Invoice Generator